Getting a Seller to Take Less Than Asking Price
Sellers don't take less because you demanded it. They take less because you made saying yes feel reasonable.
Negotiating a property to the best possible price is one way to build Instant Equity into your property. Buying for the right price is key to your Real Estate Investment.
What follows are five ways to earn a below-asking price, the three things every successful discount rests on, and how to know when a below-asking offer can actually work.
Five Ways to Earn the Discount
A below-asking price is not taken from the seller — it is earned with evidence, presented with respect and backed by discipline.
-
Negotiate From a Position of Power.
The art of negotiating in Real Estate has been diminished to a back and forth game of matching each other's counter-offer until you meet in the middle. You must first identify the actual value of your perfect property, then illustrate ways that the subject property is not actually perfect. It’s the combination of those imperfections which justify a lower than market value offer.
Position comes from evidence. Recent comparable sales establish the market value; the property's specific shortcomings justify the gap between that value and your number. Start with identifying what the property is actually worth.
-
Make it OK for the Seller to Discount the Sale Price.
Sellers are proud of their properties. "Low-ball" offers make them less apt to sell even at market value to that buyer, much less below. Allowing the seller to feel good about you as the buyer can often give them permission to agree to a lower sale price.
Your offer presentation does this work: it frames your number as reasoned rather than opportunistic, and it keeps the conversation going instead of ending it.
-
Keep It Clean.
Sellers have an expectation of their costs when selling a property. Instead of coming in and offering a low price and asking for a laundry list of other concessions (home warranty, closing costs paid by seller, etc) consider paying for these extras yourself. Add up the costs for these items and factor those costs into your offer price.
If you could spend $2,000 extra up front and get the property for a $5,000 lower sale price, would that make it worth it to you? The seller may very well be more agreeable to your offer since they think they are not being "nickeled and dimed" on all the little things.
-
Do What You Say You Will Do.
When you say "this is my final offer" — make sure it is truly your final offer. If the offer gets rejected and you come back again later with another offer, the negotiation leverage has shifted to the seller.
When you walk away and come back 24 hours later with the same offer, the seller is much more likely to agree to close the deal.
-
Offer The Closing Argument.
Similar to the presentation of your offer this gets presented with your final counter-offer. The set-up came with the original offer. Now it's time to re-introduce yourself and separate you from other potential buyers. It’s an opportunity to thank the seller for negotiating and inform of your intent to move on to your "Plan B" unless you get a YES to your counter-offer.
A credible Plan B is what gives the closing argument its weight. If you have a genuine second choice lined up — and in most Myrtle Beach searches there is one — the seller can sense you mean it.
Every Successful Below-Asking Offer Has Three Parts
Strip away the tactics and every seller who took less said yes for the same three reasons. Miss any one of them and the negotiation usually stalls.
Why Your Number Is Right
Comparable sales plus the property's specific shortcomings. Without it, a low offer is just an opinion.
Why It's OK to Say Yes
A presentation that respects the seller's pride in their home and gives them permission to take the deal.
Why They Believe You
Clean terms and a final offer that is actually final. Credibility is the leverage that survives the counter-offers.
Evidence without empathy reads as an attack. Empathy without discipline reads as a bluff. You need all three in the same offer.
When Below Asking Works — and When It Doesn't
The same offer that wins one negotiation loses another. Four things tell you how much room there really is.
Supply and Demand
Months of supply decides your room to negotiate. Over six months and sellers listen; under four, below-asking offers mostly lose to other buyers.
Identifying Value
Quality properties priced correctly rarely take less — they sell first, at or above asking. The discount lives in listings with fixable flaws or ambitious pricing.
Days on Market
Time on market is public leverage. The longer a listing sits past its segment's average, the more reasonable your number looks — the current averages are in the market report.
Seller Motivation
The quiet variable. A seller who has already bought elsewhere is negotiating a different deal than one testing the market. My negotiating guide covers reading it — and using it.
None of this makes an insulting offer work. It tells you where a justified below-market offer has a real chance — and where you would just be handing the home to the next buyer in line.
Build Your Case With Data
A below-asking offer is only as strong as the evidence behind it. The comparable sales, market pace and true cost of the purchase are all here on this site.
Sign up for an account and watch the price-drop alerts — they show you which sellers are already moving their number.
“A seller takes less when saying yes feels reasonable — not when they've been beaten down.”
Let Me Be Your Guide
Getting a seller below asking is case-building work: pulling the right comparable sales, documenting the shortcomings that justify the number, and presenting it in a way that keeps the seller at the table. That is exactly the work I do for my buyers.
It also takes an honest read on when the discount is not there — when the smarter play is competing to win the home instead. And for the full set of levers beyond price, see How to Negotiate as a Home Buyer.
Let me be your guide to purchasing a home in Myrtle Beach. Please refer to my Buying a Home page for greater detail about my process of helping you purchase the perfect home at the best possible price.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I get a seller to accept less than asking price?
Build a case instead of just naming a number: comparable sales that establish market value, the property's specific shortcomings that justify the gap, a respectful presentation that lets the seller feel good about saying yes, and clean terms with no laundry list of extras.
Do low-ball offers work in Myrtle Beach?
Rarely as a blunt instrument. An unjustified low offer usually offends the seller and ends the conversation — sometimes even at market value. A below-market offer backed by evidence is a different thing entirely, and that one can work.
What justifies offering below asking price?
Comparable sales that come in under the list price, condition issues and dated finishes, long days on market relative to the segment, and seller motivation. The more of these you can point to, the more reasonable your number looks.
Is it better to ask for a lower price or more concessions?
When your goal is the lowest price, keep the offer clean: pay for the extras yourself and push the savings into the price instead. Sellers respond better to one clear number than to a low price plus a list of requests.
What if the seller rejects my final offer?
Mean what you said and walk away. If it was truly your ceiling, coming back with more teaches the seller your "final" offers are not final. Walking away and returning 24 hours later with the same offer often closes the deal on your terms.
Let's Work Together.
Watching a property that's priced above what it's worth? Let's build the case that brings the number down.
Contact Me Call AshleySign Up For An Account Today!
Get access to real-time updates as listings hit the market. By signing up early in the process, you maximize your chances of landing your ideal home, condo, or villa.
- Save searches based on your criteria.
- Receive market updates and price drops.
- Create custom predictive market reports.
Myrtle Beach Areas
Resort & Luxury Communities
Gated, oceanfront and golf communities along the Grand Strand.
- Barefoot Resort
- Briarcliffe Acres
- Dunes Club
- Dunes Ocean Frontoceanfront
- Grande Dunes
- Kingston Plantation